Tb2018, interesting take.
I intend to dive into the concepts you presented when time allows. Here are some 'off the hip' comments, reactions of mine.
Important foundation here is a notion that BS model, when applied standard way, can lead a trader to make false decisions.
The main thing, in my opinion, is that all t-lines derived from the model are not static. This feature is embedded in 'the whole picture' of options modeling and does not matter what changes to the model you apply. I refer to this as t lines being flexible and the only rigid thing is an expiration graph. You mentioned it.
I also believe _all_ options traders do know this but act as t-lines were rigid anyway.
There can be many approaches to this 't-line flexibility' issue. Most common, imo, is to gain experience, that is to consciously observe what happens with your greeks over time in real not on the modeled graphs.
Theta is, yet again, imo (but all I say is 'imo') the most missunderstood of the greeks. In my take theta is a measurement of ' flexibility state of t line' - but it depends...
I guess I sound like babbling...
Thanks for the post. I didn't really thought of actively seeking long gamma, earning decay trades. I avoid quant's approach for practical reasons but there might be something in what you wrote to use quant method to find those trades.
Indeed this is very interesting idea... Wonder if you've already found systematic way to scan option chains for opportunities. Maybe you can share some examples of configurations giving long gamma, earning - structures.